Everyboyd's laughin' in the world
Rumors spreadin' 'bout this other girl
Do you do what did when you did with me
Does she love you the way I can
Did you forget all the plans that you made with me
'Cause baby I didn't
That should be me
Holdin' your hand
That should be me 
Makin' you laugh
That should be me
This is so sad
That should be me
That should be me
That should be me
Feelin' your kiss
That should be me
Buyin' you gifts
This is so wrong
I can't go on 
Until you believe that
That should be me
That should be me
You said you needed a little time 
For my mistakes
Funny how you used that time
To have me replaced
Did you think that 
I wouldn't see you 
Out at the movies
What you're doin' to me
You're takin' her where we used to go
Now, if you're tryin' to break my heart
it's working 'cause you know
That should be me
Holdin' your hand
That should be me 
Makin' you laugh
That should be me
This is so sad
That should be me
That should be me
That should be me
Feelin' your kiss
That should be me
Buyin' you gifts
This is so wrong
I can't go on 
Until you believe that
That should be me
That should be me
I need to know: Should I fight for love,
Or disarm? 
It's getting harder to shield
The pain in my heart
That should be me
Holdin' your hand
That should be me 
Makin' you laugh
That should be me
This is so sad
That should be me
That should be me
That should be me
Feelin' your kiss
That should be me
Buyin' you gifts
This is so wrong
I can't go on 
Until you believe that
That should be me
That should be me
Holding your hand 
Oh, and makin' you laugh
Oh, baby
That should be me, oh
Givin' you flowers
Talking for hours
Yeah
That should be me
I never shoulda let you go
I never shoulda let you go
I never shoulda let you go, oh 
That should be me