We've been sitting on the fence for far too long

 Annas
 Why let him upset us? Ciaphas, let him be.
 All those imbecils will see he really doesn't matter.

 Caiaphas
 But Jesus is important! We've let him go his way before
 And while he starts a major war, we theorize and chatter.

 Annas
 He's just another scripture thumping hack from Galilee.

 Caiaphas
 The difference is they call him king, the difference frightens me.
 What about the Romans? When they see king Jesus crowned
 Do you think they'll stand around cheering and applauding?
 What about our people? If they see we've lost our nerve,
 Don't you think that they deserve something more rewarding?

 Annas
 They've got what they want, they think so anyway.
 If he's what they want, why take their toy away? He's a craze.

 Caiaphas
 Put yourself in my place. (i can't remember this line....)
 Cannot let my hands be tied, I am law and order.
 What about our priesthood? Don't you see that we could fall?
 If we are to last at all, we cannot be devided.

 Annas

 Then say so to the council, but don't rely on subtly.
 Frighten them, or they won't see.

 Caiaphas
 Then we are decided?

 Annas
 Then we are decided