We agreed that it was over
Now the lines have all been drawn
Vows we made
Began to fade
But now they're gone

Put your pictures in a shoebox
And my gold ring in a drawer
I'm not supposed to love you anymore

Now Sherri says she's jealous
Of this freedom that I found
If she were me, she would be
Out on the town

And she says she can't imagine
What on earth I'm waitin' for
I'm not supposed to love you anymore

Oh I shouldn't care or wonder where and how you are
But I can't hide this hurt inside my broken heart
I'm fighting back emotions that I've never fought before
Cause I'm not supposed to love you anymore

Now I'm writin you this letter
And it's killing me tonight
That I agreed, when you believed it wasn't right
And I couldn't sleep up on the bed
So I'm down here on the floor
Where I'm not supposed to love you anymore

Oh I shouldn't care or wonder where and how you are
But I can't hide this hurt inside my broken heart
I'm fightin back emotions that I've never fought before
Cause I'm not supposed to love you anymore

I'm fightin back emotions that I've never fought before
Cause I'm not supposed to love you anymore