Well im a huge evanescence fan and i thought this album was excellent. The mix of Ame Lee's BEAutiful voice and the hard rocking guitars and drums really did it for me. I love the album soo much just because of the pure quality and originality of the songs. My personal favs are taking over me and holding my last breath. 100000000 out of 10 for me (i was always bad at maths ^^)

Fallen = totally perfect
all songs get 10/10
I love the piano and I love it with hard rock and gothic dark lyrics and amy's voice.
My Immortal and hello are the slow songs with the piano and they are perfect.So beautiful lyrics... they sometimes make me cry!
Best 4 songs are:
Bring me to life - nice music and lyrics and catcy
Everybody's fool - no something special with the music but veeery good lyrics.(Video clip is good too.)
My Immortal - this song made me buy the album.
Whisper - Heavy gothic one