I heard you saw her last night at that dive down in Jamestown
I haven't seen her since the 4th of July
Did you get a chance to talk, did she mention me at all?
Was she there alone or with some other guy?

Well, I'm dying to know but I'm scared of the truth
So before you say a word, consider what this heart's been through

And lie - don't tell me that she looked amazing
Just lie - if she's with someone else I just can't take it
Tell me she looked sad and lonely
Tell me she's been missing me like crazy
Yeah, just look me in the eye and lie

Was she over by the jukebox playing songs we used to dance to
Staring at the door sipping makers on the rocks
Did she ask you where I've been, was she hoping I'd walk in
Just take her by the hand and pick up right where we left off

Well, I know she's moving on and it's killing me to see
And the words you want to say are strong enough to be the death of me,

So lie - don't tell me that she looked amazing
Just lie - if she's with someone else I just can't take it
Tell me she looked sad and lonely
Tell me she's been missing me like crazy
Yeah, just look me in the eye and lie

'Cause I can't throw away the dreams we've shared
I've tried reaching out but she don't care
It's pretty clear, but I ain't ready to let go

So lie - don't tell me that she looked amazing
Just lie - if she's with someone else

Then lie - don't tell me that she looked amazing
Just lie - if she's with someone else I just can't take it
Tell me she looked sad and lonely
Tell me she's been missing me like crazy
Yeah, just look me in the eye then lie
Then lie