It was one of those nights 
When the moon was just right 
Something good was gonna happen 
I could feel it inside 
That's when I saw her 
At a club called 'Simply Blues' 
And the way that we connected 
Should have made front page news 

She had an electric smile 
And an air of confidence 
Why she was there alone 
Didn't make no sense 
I said, 'Let's get out of here. 
Hey, ain't you tired of this?' 
She said, 'Well, you put it like that, 
How could I resist?' 

She was a beautiful, beautiful heartache 
Beautiful chance I had to take 
She was a beautiful, beautiful heartache 
It hurt so good... 
I'd gladly make the same mistake 

It didn't take long till I was over my head 
So many promises were made 
So many things got said 
I loved her and I thought that she loved me 
But some things in this world 
Well, they just ain't meant to be 

She was a beautiful, beautiful heartache 
Beautiful chance I had to take 
She was a beautiful, beautiful heartache 
It hurt so good... 
I'd gladly make the same mistake 

No regerets, no tears, no feeling sorry now 
That's just a door that had to close 
I knew going in that it might not work out 
That's just the way the story, 
That's just the way the story goes

She was a beautiful, beautiful heartache 
Beautiful chance I had to take 
She was a beautiful, beautiful heartache 
It hurt so good... 
I'd gladly make the same mistake 

I was over my head 
It was one of those nights...