So many crazy memories of you and me
Like the time we drove to the OC
Got so lost we thought we would never get home
You know the night when I gave my heart to you
And you swore that you felt the same too
You said that you would never ever leave me alone

Out of nowhere you were gone
Into someone else's arms
Should have known that she was more than just a friend 
All the things I never knew
But I always trusted you
Never thought that she would wind up in the end
Your new girlfriend (your new girlfriend)

I believe what goes around comes around
So stay out of the deep end or you'll both drown
Even shallow water is over her head
You broke my heart but, hey, baby, life goes on
Everything is down for a reason
Now I can see for me there's something better ahead

Out of nowhere you were gone
Into someone else's arms
Should have known that she was more than just a friend 
All the things I never knew
But I always trusted you
Never thought that she would wind up in the end
Your new girlfriend

I don't know what I was thinking to let us get this far 
'Cos now that I see who you really are
You can have a new girlfriend

Out of nowhere you were gone
Into someone else's arms
Should have known that she was more than just a friend 
Deep inside I think I knew
But I always trusted you
Never thought that she would wind up in the end

Your new girlfriend (ha ah ha)
Your new girlfriend (ha ah ha)
Your new girlfriend (ha ah ha)
Your new girlfriend (ha ah ha)
Your new girlfriend (ha ah ha)
Your new girlfriend (ha ah ha)
Your new girlfriend (ha ah ha)
Your new girlfriend