By now I really should be over you
But I might as well just give up trying
You've got what's missing deep inside me
And I want it back, girl, you know it's mine

Send back my heart if you don't want it
Send back my heart, girl, the one you stole away
You've made it plain, your name's not on it
So don't put me through one more blue and lonely day
Send back my heart

I've found somebody else who wants my love
But I can't give her what she needs
The very thing she's wanting still ain't mine to give
So won't you let it go, please, baby, please

Send back my heart if you don't want it
Send back my heart, girl, the one you stole away
You've made it plain, your name's not on it
So don't put me through one more blue and lonely day
Send back my heart

I've tried to forget you, girl, just like you told me to
But, baby, that's impossible, so now it's up to you

Send back my heart if you don't want it
Send back my heart, girl, the one you stole away
You've made it plain, your name's not on it
So don't put me through one more blue and lonely day
Send back my heart
Send back my heart
Send back my heart