Once I thought two happy hearts could someday beat as one 
But then the third heart came along and now our love is gone 
I count the many times I've said I love no one but you
But don't be fooled by counting dreams that never will come true

Subtract one love and multiply the heartaches 
The answer only tells us that it's too late
Subtract one love and multiply the heartache

Subtract one love and multiply the heartaches
Divide the tears by every time a heart breaks
The answer only tells us that it's too late
Subtract one love, and multiply the heartaches
Subtract one love, and multiply the heartaches