Thought we were magic
Turns out I was seeing us through
Those tinted glasses
But I guess everyday you learn something new

It's like I've awoken
From a dream, from the fairytale in my head
My fickle emotions
Plus I've given them to somebody else instead

'Cause you look the same as you did yesterday
But your touch ain't the way that it was
My eyes begging to see you so differently
I don't know if it could be because

I've been in love with a stranger all this time
I've been in love with a stranger all this time
You've become someone I don't recognize
Have I been in love with a stranger all this time

This time
I see you changing
You're not the man I knew before
So close to breaking
'Cause I don't know who you are anymore

I thought we made it (made it)
Built a house out of brick and stone
We've lost our foundations
Thought you'd keep me warm, but you left me out in the cold

'Cause you look the same as you did yesterday
But your touch ain't the way that it was
My eyes begging to see you so differently
I don't know if it could be because

I've been in love with a stranger all this time
I've been in love with a stranger all this time
You've become someone I don't recognize
Have I been in love with a stranger all this time
This time
This time

And I wish the man I'd fallen for would be here tonight
It's like I've been in love with a stranger all of this time
And I wish the man I'd fallen for would be here tonight
It's like I've been in love with a stranger all of this time

You've become someone I don't recognize
Have I been in love with a stranger all this time

Have I been in love, been in love, been in love
Have I been in love, been in love, been in love