Get an eyelash, make a wish
Everybody has done this
I'm wishing on a star tonight
And it won't happen if I'm right
I've given up on silly things
Childish ways and fantasies
But I still have a dream
Of you lying here with me

[Chorus]
It's 11:11 PM
Start all over again
You & I were meant to end
Gonna play that song again
Play that song again

Wear a locket, save your life
But nobody is saving mine
Magic numbers and birthday candles
It's the truth I cannot handle
But the streets are wet round here
Because of all of my tears
Cry a river, build a bridge
I've got to get over it

[Chorus]
It's 11:11 PM
Start all over again
You & I were meant to end
Gonna play that song again
Play that song again

An angel won't do you good
If you aren't living as you should
Swore to God that I would
Just because I thought I could

[Chorus]
It's 11:11 PM
Start all over again
You & I were meant to end
Gonna play that song again
Play that song again

[Chorus]
It's 11:11 PM
Start all over again
You & I were meant to end
Gonna play that song again
Play that song again

Get an eyelash, make a wish